the dissident frogman

2 years and 10 months ago

September 2021: only the dead

We haven't seen the end of war but after twenty years, our defeat looks ineluctable.

the dissident frogman

Necrothreading much?

Article content

Article copy

Only the dead have seen the end of war—goes the saying, as popularized by Hollywood in the Islamist eulogy “Black Hawk Down”

Released a mere two months after the most devastating surprise offensive in the oldest and longest war the West has ever faced, the Ridley Scott movie opens with this quote that the supposedly “perfectionist” movie director wrongly attributes to Plato—George Santayana, who penned it, be damned:

Only the dead are safe; only the dead have seen the end of war. Not that non-existence deserves to be called peace; it is only by an illusion of contrast and a pathetic fallacy that we are tempted to call it so.George Santayana, Soliloquies in England and Later Soliloquies (1922)

I’ve always been in the minority when it comes to the appraisal of Scott’s depictions of the 1993 Mogadishu battle. Many people, particularly so close after the September attacks in America, saw this movie as a great tribute to the American—and, by extension and association, Western—warriors.

I disagree.

I’ve seen the movie several times and always with the same deeply mixed feelings; while Black Hawk Down is stylistically superb, despite a slew of ridiculously miscast English actors, it is ideologically repugnant. I do not throw down the words “Islamist eulogy” lightly: the movie progresses along the lines of a most boorish Soviet propaganda feature film. The U.S soldiers (and only them) are depicted as swaggering and overconfident before the battle starts, then as a blundering panicky bunch getting kicked left and right by the “skinnies”, only to end in what is both the climax and the real purpose of the whole movie: showing us their casualties carried away by a relief convoy mostly made of Pakistani Muslim troops, and the rest on foot running away, chased like dogs by Somali Muslim militia.

I don’t know about the book, but when it comes to the movie, I’m quite certain that neither al-Qaeda or ISIS could achieve the same propaganda coup for their evil cause as Ridley Scott did.1

It’s only a movie, of course, and as such totally insignificant compared to the heinous act of war perpetrated by the same foes two months before that movie opened in American theaters.

Yet here we are 20 years later and far from crushing, or at the very least pushing back and stalling Islamic aggression—as our ancestors did repeatedly since this death cult started to spread—the West including America is on the run, each of us on our own respective lands.

Which begs the question: where the Hell are we running to?

Every nation that forms the core of Occidental culture is now under direct assault, each of them at various stages of occupation and defeat. The question has long ceased to be about which ones can survive but is now a guessing game of which one will fall first—France coming in pole position so far.

A few of our kin in Eastern Europe are putting up a fight, but how long can they hold once all the Western shores pass into enemy hands? Even the traditional strongholds of the West are in critical state—the U.K.—or getting there fast—the U.S.A.

In frequent alliances of circumstance or convenience with Muhammad’s zealots, most of those that pretend to manage the Polis for the common good have been actively working at destroying it and replacing it by a totalitarian nightmare without precedent, magnified by the technological advances of the very culture they aim to destroy. The rest are at best useless or too few to make a difference. From merely academic malfeasance, La Trahison des Clercs2 has morphed into full frontal assault from all sides: politics, education, media and entertainment, corporate and non-profit alike.

It doesn’t matter if the unholy alliance between Globalists of all stripes and Islamists is worth hardly more than the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact, it doesn’t matter which one is using the other to better advance their cause, and it doesn’t really matter which one will ultimately come on top: they’ve been holding fast and largely winning for the last 20 years—I don’t need to remind you all the ground we’ve lost, particularly over the last decade, and exponentially so over the last year.

It’s no comfort at all to know that these two will get at each other’s throat at some point, for they will fight over our civilization’s corpse. Whether the faction that topples statues of great men in the West or the one that dynamites monumental Buddhas in the East wins over the other will make little difference to us.

20 years on, and the verdict is clear: we failed. Like so many other cults before it—large or small, religious or not—Islam should now be reduced to a dark chapter of human history, alongside Thuggee and Naziism, or at the very least confined to the most remote and backward ends of this Earth, slowly drifting to extinction. We failed to heed or ignored the warnings of those who came before us, from Bernard of Clairvaux to Jefferson and Churchill, and countless others who witnessed or opposed the scourge of Islam before us.

We failed the innocent victims of September 11 and those killed in practically every Western nation and beyond ever since. We failed all those who took arms and offered their time, efforts and sometimes their lives to fight back and defend the West in a war many of us were not even willing to fight, let alone win. We failed our forefathers who did the same before them. We failed ourselves and more importantly, we failed our descendants.

Rome fell, but the idea of Rome lived on. The “barbarians” who came after Rome valued her more than most Roman citizens did and wanted to preserve what was worth preserving and improve what could be improved. Thanks to them, the fall of Rome ushered in a new and glorious beginning for this greatest civilization.

Those that are coming now only mean to destroy what’s left of it.

And so far, they are succeeding.

  1. Anybody still in doubt of “Sir” Ridley Scott’s impeccable Islamophile credentials only has to watch the revisionist Crusade flick he directed and produced a few years after Black Hawk Down: the nauseating Kingdom of Heaven.
  2. The Treason of the IntellectualsJulien Benda



the dissident frogman's avatar
the dissident frogman

I own, built and run this place. In a previous life I was not French but sadly, I died.


To reveal my email address, find the 5th  number in the code and enter it in the challenge field below.


The Wise knows that Cities are but demonic Soul-tearing pits that shall not be entered.

More options


Random (somewhat) related entries

  1. So, an ayatollah walks into a gay bar…


Commenting as

You're presumed to have read and abide by the comments policy, but here's the gist of it:

Silly or serious, you are responsible for what you write. I slay trolls. Thank you for your comment.

Comment author avatar
Max. 300 characters
An email address is required.
It is never published or shared.

As in "valid" email address...

Once posted, your comment can't be edited. Feel free to (ab)use the Preview!

The Wise knows that Cities are but demonic Soul-tearing pits that shall not be entered.

Comments thread (8)

5228 - TooTall

Comment author avatar

You noted that the left always ends up turning on itself which is true. I’m afraid that this won’t happen until they manage to destroy us first. I never thought this would happen in my lifetime,

5229 - the dissident frogman

Comment author avatar
  • the dissident frogman France

You and me both TooTall.

Time to take sides

5230 - Quoth the Raven

Comment author avatar
  • Quoth the Raven Alone, in the mountains, occasional contact with people I love, surrounded by snow but still, with lots of wood available for the fire. And lots of ammo. Oh yes.

I have a theory. I don’t know if it will play out, but I think the materialism of the west will win. I don’t think that is a great outcome, but it is better than the obvious alternative. I think when fanatic’s kids live in a richer, more open culture, they start to enjoy owning shit and aren’t as happy with wearing a burka, when they can wear jeans, a trendy tee, and a hijab. It will take awhile for this to work. Dumbass losers will still probably go to the shitholes where *sl*m rules in order to learn their trade of terrorism. Up to this point though more of them have to come here to drink and wench before they blow themselves up on our soil- so the Islamofascists are importing them to us because they haven’t been able to grow their own here as effectively as they likely thought. I think it is harder to get a person raised in the lap of western prosperity to blow themselves up than someone raised in the shitholes these people currently run.

Again, I could be wrong. This thought is a rare moment of dark optimism for me so please indulge me, however briefly.

Only time will tell. I’m not likely to see it play itself out to the end, but if we’re all going to suffer, I’d love to see AOC forced to wear the hijab and pushed aside to give a place to her Muslim overlords. Maybe forced to go back to her bar and serve camel milk to women and children.

5241 - Quoth the Raven

Comment author avatar
  • Quoth the Raven Alone, in the mountains, occasional contact with people I love, surrounded by snow but still, with lots of wood available for the fire. And lots of ammo. Oh yes.

Thinking about you, Frogman. Hoping you are doing well. As thanksgiving approaches here in the US, I am thankful for you.

Best wishes.

5264 - safAlgor

Comment author avatar

big ass wife

✂ ✂


5265 - safAlgor

Comment author avatar

big tits milf ass

✂ ✂


5266 - safAlgor

Comment author avatar

lingerie for teens

✂ ✂


5294 - readerjp

Comment author avatar

No blogpost on France’s nationalization of energy? Or on Macron’s reelection? How is an American capitalist supposed to know how to think?