the dissident frogman

16 years and 2 months ago

The (translated) French Economy Quote of the Day

Hey, just because it didn't work for the last 40 years doesn't mean we should stop trying.

the dissident frogman

Necrothreading much?

Article content

Article copy

There are but a few economists not from the Marx / Keynes school of thought in this country:
Liberal1 countries invented the " flat tax » ; we invented the " full tax »
French economist Jean-Louis Caccomo, lamenting on the appalling state of Gallic economic knowledge and understanding, the resulting ambient stupidity and French panic over the slowing down of the U.S. economy, and the typical deadly and counterproductive measures to be expected, once again, from the French "authorities" in yet another professed attempt to "shield" the moribund French economy from the shockwaves of global recession: none of the critically needed reforms of the humungous State machine, even more public spending and, obligatory corollary, more taxes.

I'm roughly of the same age as J.L. Caccomo, and like him I've heard about the country's constant economic crisis, massive and ever growing unemployment rates on par with public spending and taxation, and therefore "requiring" a plethora of government "plans" measures and intervention that only make things worse, ever since I was old enough to understand articulate language.

Over these decades, and among the "people in charge", virtually nobody in France figured what "those stupid Americans" have known for some time: that the government can't be the solution to our problems, considering it is the problem.

Predictably — and as predicted here — Sarkozy is not different at all, and has already warned that, quote, " the coffers (sic) were empty » implying that, you know, very sorry and all, but the promised tax relief will have to be "postponed" — to provide some relief to the lavish lifestyle of the French State and sustainable opportunities for the creative minds of French technocrat-taxmen. Some eminent members of his government followed up, and start making the buzzing noise of tax raise, so common under these tropics ; Sarkozy himself set the example by devising a tax on Internet access to make for the loss of revenue in his plan of banning advertising on all state owned TV channels2.

As noted by J.L. Caccomo — who was initially cautiously hopeful about the Super Sarko, but then nobody's perfect — even the Socialists agree about the "ineluctability of tax raise" in France's immediate future. Socialists always do.

Confronted to that pack of mobsters and racketeers, I submit that in France tax evasion is not just an act of civil disobedience but a true civic duty3.
  1. Warning, cultural shift alert: "liberal" here is to be taken in the European meaning of the word (classical liberalism), i.e. free market capitalism, property rights, limited government, etc. Think Adam Smith, not Michael Moore.
  2. A breathtaking exploit. Even the numerous French far-left parties — and we're talking hardcore Communist revolutionaries here, people — didn't dare pulling this one out. Small wonder the French Socialists at large are in such a state of confusion: Sarkozy keeps passing them from the left.
  3. Nah, I'm not particulary pissed. I've been beyond that point for years.



the dissident frogman's avatar
the dissident frogman

I own, built and run this place. In a previous life I was not French but sadly, I died.


To reveal my email address, find the 4th  number in the code and enter it in the challenge field below.


The Wise knows that Cities are but demonic Soul-tearing pits that shall not be entered.

More options


Commenting as

You're presumed to have read and abide by the comments policy, but here's the gist of it:

Silly or serious, you are responsible for what you write. I slay trolls. Thank you for your comment.

Comment author avatar
Max. 300 characters
An email address is required.
It is never published or shared.

As in "valid" email address...

Once posted, your comment can't be edited. Feel free to (ab)use the Preview!

The Wise knows that Cities are but demonic Soul-tearing pits that shall not be entered.

Comments thread (4)

3348 - 2hotel9

Comment author avatar
  • 2hotel9 Western Pennsylvania

No matter how hard the stone, smack it long enough and it will break. Sorry to have say it, Froggy, but most of Europe is standing knee deep in crushed stone, and crushing more as we speak. And wondering, in a dazed, puzzled sort of way, why there is so much crushed stone instead of solid rock under foot.

3349 - DGB

Comment author avatar


Right, left, vote them into office and it's the same big club. The drawback to politicians running the country is that they are too damn busy getting elected or re-elected to, well, run the country.

In every government in the world there is a dark room. In this room is a table wtih a cabled box and a folding chair. In the center of the box is a worn button. The button is labelled (for the newly elected), "AUTOPILOT". Press this button and the polity is taxed more, the government spends more, and somewhere another form is generated.

Socialist governments have a box with several buttons. The number of buttons pressed does not affect the increase in tax, but Socialists sit for hours on end pressing the buttons. They just like pressing the buttons.


3351 - the dissident frogman

Comment author avatar
  • the dissident frogman France


Yep, tell me about it :)


Hey, long time no speak! I agree with you globally, however I believe (suspect? hope? pray?!) that not every nation was made equal in the dark room with autopilot button Department.

I'm under the impression that in some luckier places on this planet, the button happens to break (possibly just as much as everywhere else) but the Button Guys whose jobs it is to fix them (politicos being useless at any manual and technical task, as we both know) pretend they have a huge backlog, or some other clever excuse not to do the job without aggravating the client.

I've heard the other day that the "black" budget of the presidential palace (mandatory "gifts" from each ministry to the Elysée, according to their importance, and meant only for the President's office "representation" costs - basically booze and babes for the President, his retinue and all their tribal chieftains guests from every corners of Africa and the Middle East, while on their frequent State visit to harvest visas, infinite term loans and crappy jet fighters for the less lucky) went from 35 millions under Mitterrand to more than 80 under Sarkozy -- even though the same Sarkozy claimed he put that old disgraceful "tradition" to an end.

I wonder how much is devoted to the Button Fixing Company...

Time to take sides

3353 - TooTall

Comment author avatar

[quote]Over these decades, and among the "people in charge", virtually nobody in France figured what "those stupid Americans" have known for some time: that the government can't be the solution to our problems, considering it is the problem.

If one considers the popularity of the leading Democratic canidate here in the United States this may well be a history lesson than will have to be relearned. The Republican Party here which has stood for smaller government and less regulation has also started a trend towards the "nanny" government which I find worrisome. Hopefully the United States will never devolve quite as deeply as the European countires but there are signs that it's drifting that way.